Find a lawyerOur capabilitiesYour career
Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

hamburger menu showcase image
  1. Our thinking
  2. Blogs
  3. Sustainability
  4. Oregon District Court Conditionally Reinstates EPR Law Injunction
3MIN

Oregon District Court Conditionally Reinstates EPR Law Injunction

Subscribe
Nov 18 2026

Three months after upholding Oregon’s extended producer responsibility (EPR) law against a constitutional challenge, a federal district court has conditionally reinstated an injunction prohibiting enforcement against the plaintiffs while the case is on appeal. 

On November 16, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon granted plaintiff National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors’ (NAW) motion for a stay of the court’s August 28, 2026 judgment upholding, on constitutional grounds, Oregon’s EPR law, the Plastic Pollution and Recycling Modernization Act (RMA), pending appeal of the judgment. The court had issued a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the law against the NAW’s members on February 6, 2026, but the injunction automatically dissolved as a result of the court’s August 2026 judgment. The court will reinstate that injunction pending appeal, but only once it has approved and received a bond from the NAW that is approximately equivalent to the amount of unpaid annual fees that would be owed by members of the NAW if the judgment is affirmed on appeal. Our blog on the August 2026 decision in NAW v. Feldon can be found here: https://www.freshfields.com/en/our-thinking/blogs/sustainability/oregons-epr-law-survives-crucial-court-test-and-what-it-signals-for-colorado-102nzp4

On October 16, 2026, the NAW filed a motion to stay the August judgment, and reinstate the preliminary injunction, pending appeal. In granting the NAW’s motion, the court stated that it is not concluding that the NAW is “likely to succeed on the merits” of its appeal. But the court stated that the NAW has raised serious questions, and that the NAW made a strong argument that its members will likely suffer irreparable harm without an injunction pending appeal if it were to prevail because they would be required to pay annual fees under the RMA to the Circular Action Alliance (CAA), which they likely could not recover if they prevail. The court also agreed with Oregon that members who defer paying fees for several years would gain a competitive advantage over fee-paying competitors that is “both unfair and not speculative.” To address both concerns, the court made the stay and injunction effective only upon the NAW’s deposit of the bond noted above with the court. 

The RMA requires that companies qualifying as “producers” under the law join and pay fees to the CAA, with fees scaled according to environmental impact. A producer of a covered product can be a brand owner, licensee, importer, or distributor of a “covered product”—that is, certain packaging, food serviceware, or paper products—depending on who brings the product to market in Oregon. Exemptions include operators of single, non-franchised retail establishments without online sales and companies generating less than $5 million per year worldwide or selling less than one metric ton of covered products in the state. The RMA required that producers join the CAA by July 1, 2025. Producers that do not comply with the RMA may be subject to fines of up to $25,000 per day per violation. In April 2026, the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) published its first list of noncompliant producers in Oregon, giving those producers 90 days to respond.

 While the court’s decision provides a compliance reprieve for the members of the NAW once the bond is in place, other in-scope companies will need to continue to comply with the RMA, and DEQ enforcement against them continues. The court’s August 2026 decision will likely continue to serve as key precedent as other courts consider constitutional challenges to state EPR schemes, including in California and Colorado. 

To receive the latest ESG developments globally, subscribe to the Freshfields Sustainability Blog.

Tags

circular economyenvironmental lawenvironment and climateenvironment social and governanceenvironmental disputesplanning and environmental lawunited states

Authors

New York

John Rousakis

Partner
New York

Kelly Bridges

Associate
New York

Ginger Hervey

Associate
Latest Insights

Latest Insights

NAVIGATE TO
About usLocations and officesYour careerOur thinkingOur capabilitiesNews
CONNECT
Find a lawyerAlumniContact us
NEED HELP
Fraud and scamsComplaintsTerms and conditions
LEGAL
AccessibilityCookiesLegal noticesTransparency in supply chains statementResponsible procurementPrivacy

Select language:
Select language:
© 2026 Freshfields. Attorney Advertising: prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome