The latest proposals for SMCR revisions - simplification but not relaxation
On 22 October 2026, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) published consultation papers (CP26/37 and CP14/26 respectively) on the next stage of reforms to the Senior Managers & Certification Regime (SMCR). The aim is to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the SMCR rules and reduce unnecessary regulatory and compliance burden.
A series of initial targeted changes, the Phase 1 reforms, were implemented earlier this year (see here for further detail). The latest consultation papers address Phase 2 reforms, which require legislative amendment, to be implemented under the Financial Services and Markets Bill 2026 (the Bill). The changes will empower the regulators to specify, via rules and guidance, key elements of the revised SMCR regime. Significant proposed areas of change include the introduction of notification-only requirements for certain Senior Manager Function (SMF) positions, the withdrawal of the certification regime and (in relation to some individuals) a relaxation of breach reporting requirements under the Conduct Rules.
Although the reforms should lead to considerable simplification, simplification should not be interpreted as equating to a relaxation of standards or individual accountability. There may be less in the way of form-filling and fewer direct interactions with the regulators on SMCR matters, but the substantive requirements and expectations for firms will remain significant.
The consultation remains open until 22 January 2027. Final rules are expected to be published in the first half of 2027, with the rules coming into force in the second half of 2027 (although implementation is subject to enactment of the Bill). It would be prudent for firms to begin to consider now how they might be affected.
Reducing the number of SMF applications and notification requirements
One of the key proposals is to make a significant number of SMF roles subject to regulatory notification rather than (as now) prior regulatory approval. The FCA proposes that this should be the case for several functions in dual-regulated and Enhanced Scope SMCR firms (the larger, more complex or higher risk firms subject to the highest tier of the SMCR regime). The functions that will become notifiable only are SMF5 Head of Internal Audit, SMF10 Chair of Risk Committee, SMF11 Chair of the Audit Committee, SMF12 Chair of the Remuneration Committee, SMF13 Chair of the Nomination Committee, SMF14 Senior Independent Director and SMF15 Chair of the With-Profits Committee. These functions are considered by the FCA not to involve the same level of day-to-day executive control as other SMF functions. The FCA’s assessment is that this will reduce SMF applications from FCA solo-regulated Enhanced firms by about 15%. The PRA expects to convert nine functions into notified functions.
The FCA proposes to retain a pre-approval requirement for what would otherwise be notified functions in exceptional cases (limited to future appointments and only where the regulator has serious concerns about a firm’s governance or its ability or willingness to assess the fitness and propriety of notified SMFs, or where a role covered by a notified SMF is of particular importance to the firm’s safety and soundness, based on the firm’s circumstances).
Importantly, notified roles will remain subject to the same requirements as approved roles, including vetting and checking, with the Duty of Responsibility and Senior Manager Conduct Rules continuing to apply.
The FCA proposes what is described as a simple and streamlined notification process for those roles that will no longer require prior approval. Notification would take effect on the later of the date the FCA confirms receipt in writing and the appointment date specified in the notification (up to three months in advance of appointment).
Some FCA-only SMF roles will be removed: SMF18 (Other Overall Responsibilities) and SMF22 (Local Responsibility). SMF18 accounts for 19% of applications at solo-regulated firms and SMF22 accounts for 24% of applications at dual-regulated branches – including in roles that the FCA considers were not intended to be SMF roles. The rationale for the removal of these functions is to make the regime less burdensome to operate and avoid dilution of the FCA’s focus on the most senior individuals. As a consequence, firms are likely to need to reallocate their Prescribed Responsibilities and overall and local responsibilities to other SMFs. To help firms make these changes, it is proposed to amend SYSC 26 and COCON to allow firms to make greater use of delegation, layered management structures and governance and reporting frameworks (as an alternative, the FCA acknowledges that these roles could be converted into notified roles, which would then remove the requirement to amend SYSC 26 and COCON).
Changes are also proposed to the SMF7 function (Group Entity Senior Manager). The FCA proposes to narrow the scope of this function at solo-regulated firms by changing the definition so that it includes only individuals performing specified group or sub-group functions (Chief Executive, Chief Finance, Chief Risk, Chief Operations, Chair of the governing body, Compliance Oversight and Money Laundering Reporting Officer). However, in addition to performing the relevant function, the FCA takes the view that to fall within SMF7 an individual must also in fact exercise significant influence over the firm’s activities. Firms should, if needed, withdraw any individuals who no longer meet the proposed new definition, so they stop holding SMF7 when the rule changes. The FCA considers that this will reduce the solo-regulated SMF7 population by about 40%.
The PRA proposes taking a different approach – splitting SMF7 into two functions (SMF7, which will require approval, and SMF7a, which will only require notification). SMF7 group functions will include Group Chief Executive, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Risk Officer, Chief Operations Officer, Chief Compliance Officer, MLRO and Board Chair. SMF7a functions would capture individuals exercising significant influence, but who do not perform one of the specified SMF7 functions requiring approval. The difference in approach between the two regulators could give rise to a scenario where, for example, an individual undertaking two roles is treated as not being a SMF7 at a solo-regulated firm within a group and as a SMF7a in respect of a separate group position. Notwithstanding this, firms will welcome the greater clarity as to the scope of SMF7.
Time limited and conditional approvals
The regulators currently have a (relatively rarely used) power to approve an SMF application with conditions or time limits. The process can be burdensome because the existing legislation requires a regulatory decision notice to be issued whenever a condition is applied (even where the condition has been requested informally by the firm – firms currently cannot make a formal request for a condition to be applied). It is now proposed to formally allow dual-regulated firms, solo-regulated firms in dual-regulated groups and Enhanced Scope SMCR firms to request a time-limited or conditional approval and to make clear that, in these circumstances, no decision notice is needed.
Enhanced Scope SMCR firm thresholds
A firm categorised as an Enhanced Scope SMCR firm is subject to additional requirements (including the need for more roles to be approved as senior manager roles and requirements relating to responsibilities maps). As part of the Phase 1 reforms, many of the financial thresholds above which a firm will become an Enhanced Scope SMCR firm were increased by approximately 30%, with a mechanism introduced to enable the thresholds to be further adjusted every five years for inflation.
Now, as part of Phase 2, it is proposed to raise some thresholds further to better target the “right firms” and avoid applying enhanced requirements where the incremental risk does not justify creating additional burdens. For example, for consumer credit firms, asset managers and intermediaries, the thresholds will be raised by around 50% and for wholesale market firms, the existing SYSC threshold will be replaced with an asset-based threshold of £750 million in assets (calculated as a rolling three-year average). This is about 50% higher than the existing balance sheet assets element of the Significant SYSC definition. The PRA is also exploring the indexation of thresholds across banking, insurance and credit unions.
In certain circumstances, firms can be required to comply with the Enhanced Scope SMCR regime even where they do not exceed the relevant financial threshold (and firms can also voluntarily opt into the Enhanced Scope SMCR regime). As part of the intended changes, more detailed regulatory guidance will be prepared describing the factors that will be relevant to a determination that a smaller firm is nevertheless required to comply with the Enhanced Scope SMCR regime, noting that this may be particularly relevant to wholesale market firms.
Temporary SMF cover – the 12-week rule
The Phase 1 reforms have given firms more time to submit a senior manager application where there has been an unexpected or temporary change. Previously, firms had 12 weeks for the application to be submitted and for approval to be obtained. This was changed so that it was necessary only to submit the relevant application within the 12-week period.
It is now proposed to extend the period for submitting the relevant application from 12 weeks to 18 weeks. The FCA also proposes to remove the requirement for there to have been a “reasonably unforeseen” absence of an SMF and to replace it with rules on “reasonable use”. On the other hand, the PRA proposes to retain the “reasonably unforeseen” requirement for dual-regulated firms, which could mean different temporary cover arrangements applying within the same firm. In recognition of this, the FCA is seeking views on whether the removal of the “reasonably unforeseen” absence requirement should only apply to SMF roles in solo-regulated firms. This seems a more sensible approach to avoid inconsistency for dual-regulated firms.
Statements of Responsibilities (SoRs)
The FCA states that respondents to prior consultations have accepted that SoRs are important and useful tools for clearly allocating responsibilities to Senior Managers and supporting individual accountability. However, there is regulatory acknowledgement that the way the SoRs operate, particularly the associated reporting requirements, is administratively burdensome. The Phase 1 reforms have already introduced a relaxation in the reporting requirements for changes to SoRs, permitting them to be made within six months after a change rather than immediately. It is now proposed to remove the requirement for firms to submit updated SoRs whenever responsibilities change (so the Form J reporting requirement will be withdrawn), although a SoR will still be required with an SMF application or notification. Firms will also need to keep SoRs updated internally and retain records of superseded SoRs (and make them available to the regulators on request). In other words, the removal of the requirement to submit updated SoRs does not reduce their importance and, should a difficulty arise, the regulators will expect to see them.
The FCA is proposing a general six-year SoR retention period requirement. However, the PRA is proposing that this should be 10 years for some dual-regulated firms; the FCA will operate the same retention period for these firms.
The requirement for a SoR will be removed for firms where only one individual performs SMF roles.
Management Responsibilities Maps (MRMs)
MRM requirements apply to dual-regulated firms and Enhanced Scope solo-regulated firms. Both the PRA and the FCA propose aligned targeted changes. The MRM requirement will be removed from firms with only one individual performing SMF roles on the basis that an MRM is of limited value in these circumstances.
It is also proposed to remove the requirement to provide MRM updates routinely to the regulators (although they will need to be updated internally and made available on request). There will be a six-year retention period for MRMs, rising to 10 years for some dual-regulated firms.
Prescribed Responsibilities (PR)
PRs are specified responsibilities that must be allocated to SMFs. The aim is to ensure that responsibility for specified areas is clearly allocated to a Senior Manager. Taking account of concerns that the current list of PRs is more extensive than necessary, the FCA proposes that only three PRs should be retained for Core and Enhanced Firms (A – responsibility for the Senior Managers Regime, D – responsibility for financial crime, and Z – responsibility for CASS) and a fourth for Enhanced Firms only (J-3 – responsibility for oversight of outsourced internal audit). These PRs will be retained because they support core elements of the SMCR. The PRA is also proposing to remove PRs but will retain a longer list. This means that some PRs that are currently both FCA and PRA PRs for dual-regulated firms will become PRA-only PRs.
The regulators are at pains to emphasise that removing PRs does not remove the underlying requirements, merely the mechanism of separately recording responsibility for that area. Firms must still maintain SoRs where required and accurately record SMF responsibilities. Although the change to PRs will require some firms to update their SoRs and MRMs, it is not proposed that firms will need to do so solely because of the proposed PR changes – it can instead be done when a separate change to a SoR is next made.
Streamlining SMF application requirements
The regulators are conscious of criticism that the existing system is cumbersome and could be improved. The aim is therefore to “reduce unnecessary friction while ensuring we receive sufficient information to assess candidates effectively”.
Proposed changes include the removal of certain supporting document requirements and the removal of various forms from the Handbook, making them easier and quicker to update.
Certification Regime
It is proposed to remove the Certification Regime completely. Although the regulators acknowledge that a reduction of the formal regulatory requirements for firms to identify, assess, certify and report on individuals performing roles that currently require certification could “increase risk to a limited extent”, they conclude that the Certification Regime no longer provides sufficient additional regulatory benefit, relative to its cost to justify its continued operation as a standalone regime.
The regulators believe that the objective of certification can be achieved more proportionately through other existing requirements on employee competence and suitability operated through a firm’s own processes (in other words, removing the certification regime will not amount to a material relaxation in the obligations faced by firms in ensuring their staff are suitable for the roles they perform).
For example, under other existing requirements, firms will remain responsible for ensuring individuals in relevant roles are competent, suitable and meet appropriate standards of conduct. The competent employee rules in SYSC 3.1.6R and SYSC 5.1.1R (which require an assessment of honesty and competence) will continue to apply (and it is proposed to extend them to insurers, managing agents and the Society of Lloyd’s). In addition, the Conduct Rules will continue to apply to those currently performing certification roles. The regulators also note that firms will continue to assess competence through standard employer practices, including performance management, employment checks and referencing. Other specific requirements such as the Statement of Professional Standing will also continue to apply to relevant individuals.
The PRA also proposes to extend the “competent employee” rule so that CRR and Solvency II firms will be required to take reasonable steps to assess whether individuals currently subject to certification demonstrate the honesty and integrity to perform the role in question.
Regulatory references
Other than for individuals applying for an approved or notified SMF role (and non-SMF board directors), the regulators propose that firms no longer need to obtain regulatory references. This is on the basis that any benefits are outweighed by their costs and operational burden, with the information obtained rarely of additional value to other checks that can be performed.
From an employer perspective, this is one of the most noteworthy changes being proposed. The regulatory reference regime has significantly increased the stakes in disciplinary hearings, with adverse findings by a former employer (or even a view that circumstances have arisen which are “relevant” to an assessment of fitness and propriety) following an employee for several years and potentially impacting their ability to find new employment. These higher stakes have arguably led to greater litigation risk. Nevertheless, the regime has also offered a degree of certainty and a clear expectation as to the questions that will be asked and the information that will be provided from former to prospective employers. If the regime were removed for everyone other than SMFs, a key question for employers would be how they should now assess whether an incoming employee is competent and suitable for a role. We would expect a degree of reluctance by former employers to provide detailed information when there is no requirement to do so. Guidance from the regulators may be needed here (including the expectations as to the information that will be provided between firms on matters such as Conduct Rule determinations).
The Directory
The FCA proposes to retire the Directory of certified and assessed persons. Information about firms and individual SMFs will be available through the Financial Services Register (and consumers can also use the FCA Firm Checker).
Conduct Rules
As the FCA consultation paper notes, the Conduct Rules apply to all SMCR firms and to almost everyone working in those firms, except ancillary staff. They set minimum standards of behaviour and help promote accountability across all levels of seniority.
A number of relevant changes to the Conduct Rules are proposed. These include a more flexible approach to training, with the current training obligation replaced by a requirement to notify staff of applicable rules and the consequences of breach. It is accepted by the regulators that this may not require specific annual training. Even if training obligations are relaxed, as proposed, firms should be mindful of the continuing need to be able to demonstrate to the regulators that adequate notification of staff has taken place; failure to do so will expose them to regulatory sanction.
A further proposed change that firms are likely to welcome is a raising of the threshold for when a conduct rule notification is required. The consultation papers make clear that the aim is to make breach reporting more proportionate by targeting serious misconduct. In terms of the specifics, the proposal for non-SMF staff who are only subject to Individual Conduct Rules (which will be almost everyone working in financial services apart from SMFs and others subject to Senior Manager Conduct Rules) is to lift the reporting threshold so that it applies solely to a final written warning or dismissal. If implemented, this approach could materially change the compliance burden faced by firms on lower-level disciplinary matters for all other than the most senior staff (although firms will need to ensure that they are not applying a lower-level disciplinary sanction to avoid reporting requirements). The revised approach may also reduce a firm’s risk profile for such disciplinary matters, although consideration will still need to be given to whether notification is required under Fundamental Rule 7, Principle 11, SUP 15 or SUP 10C. Firms will therefore still be required to notify the regulators promptly of any matters of regulatory significance, including suspected or actual significant breaches of the Conduct Rules.
By contrast, there will be no change in reporting requirements for non-SMF staff who are also subject to the Senior Manager Conduct Rules (this category includes individuals providing temporary cover for SMFs, others acting as SMFs without prior approval and non-executive directors). Reporting will therefore continue to be required for any formal written warning, disciplinary suspension, dismissal or reduction or recovery of remuneration). However, reporting timing requirements will be simplified (with an obligation to report breaches within seven business days of the disciplinary decision). The same requirements will apply to SMFs.
What next?
The consultation papers propose a significant number of changes. Although implementation of the proposals should lead to a meaningful relaxation of the administrative burdens imposed by the SMCR regime, firms should start planning now for how the changes are likely to affect them in practice. The most important takeaway for firms is that they should not confuse simplification with relaxation. For example, the shift from approval to notification for certain SMF functions does not equate to a lowering of the requirements for notified roles, and firms will be unable to rely on the regulatory verification currently available via the approval process. Similarly, the removal of the certification regime will, if anything, increase the onus on firms to ensure the robustness of their internal mechanisms for determining that staff are competent, suitable and meet appropriate standard of conduct. One of the challenges firms will face in doing so is that the relaxation of the regulatory reference regime may make it harder to assess the competence and suitability of incoming employees. There is therefore a series of planning steps that requires immediate consideration and firms should be clear that SMCR reforms will not in any way lower the standards expected of them in this area.
If you would like to discuss this further, please contact the authors of this blog or your usual Freshfields contact.
