Representative actions for GDPR damages in Germany: Next up, the Federal Court of Justice
On 3 November 2026, the German Federal Court of Justice (‘FCJ’) announced that on 25 February 2027, it would hear a case giving it its first opportunity to decide whether claims for non-material damages under Art. 82 GDPR can be pursued by way of a representative action for redress (‘Abhilfeklage’). The case pits collective enforcement of a large number of similar consumer claims against the individual nature of claims for non-material damages under Art. 82 GDPR, as shaped by the Court of Justice of the European Union (‘CJEU’). At first instance, the Berlin Higher Regional Court (‘Berlin HRC’) held that such claims are too individual to be ‘essentially similar’ and therefore cannot be pursued in a redress action.
Tension between collective claim enforcement and individual claim requirements
When Germany opened the door to representative actions for redress in late 2023, many technology companies braced themselves for a wave of class actions. Data privacy looked like fertile ground: a single alleged infringement can affect millions of users, and claimant organisations promised to turn them into one lawsuit with one price tag. The open question was whether that promise could survive contact with the CJEU’s case law on non-material damages under Art. 82 GDPR, which turns on highly individual circumstances.
The 20th Senate of the Berlin HRC gave a first answer (20 VKl 1/25) and held that claims for non-material damages under Art. 82 GDPR brought in a redress action under the German Consumer Rights Enforcement Act (‘VDuG’) were inadmissible for lack of ‘similarity’. In this case, a Dutch foundation registered as a qualified entity in the Netherlands brought a redress action on behalf of users in Germany against the operator of a social media network , claiming minimum damages for alleged GDPR infringements. The dismissal is an important win for defendants, but is not the last word: the FCJ will hear the appeal on 25 February 2027 (I ZR 232/26). The FCJ’s ruling may have a significant impact on the exposure of many platforms and other data-driven businesses to collective claims for non-material damages in Germany for years to come.
Why ‘similarity’ is the bottleneck
Under the German VDuG, implementing Directive (EU) 2020/1828 on representative actions (‘RAD’), a redress action is admissible only if the consumers’ claims are ‘essentially similar’ – they must rest on the same or comparable facts and turn on essentially the same factual and legal questions. This requirement carries considerable weight.
Under Section 25 VDuG, a redress ruling is implemented by a court-appointed trustee, who distributes the collective trust funds to registered consumers who can prove their eligibility. The trustee, however, has no power to take further evidence or to hear individual consumers. The judgment itself must therefore spell out who is entitled and what each consumer has to prove. This is precisely why highly individual claims, such as Art. 82 GDPR non-material damages claims, do not fit into a redress action.
High individual requirements for claims under Art. 82 GDPR
Relying on the CJEU’s judgment of 19 March 2026 in Brillen Rottler (C-526/24), the Berlin HRC recalled that a claim for non-material damages under Art. 82 GDPR requires three cumulative conditions: a GDPR infringement, damage and a causal link between them. In that judgment, the CJEU also made clear that everything turns on the individual case: data subjects must demonstrate damage that goes beyond the mere infringement. A mere allegation of fear caused by a loss of control is not sufficient in this regard, and national courts must verify whether such fear is well founded ‘in the specific circumstances at issue and with regard to the data subject’ (Brillen Rottler, para. 63; see our further analysis of the CJEU’s Brillen Rottler judgment here). This is in line with the CJEU’s earlier case law, including its ruling of 4 September 2025 in Quirin Privatbank (C-655/23), where it held that a loss of control may only be sufficient to ‘cause’ non-material damage if the data subject demonstrates that he or she has actually suffered such damage (Quirin Privatbank, para. 60). This shows that a mere loss of control does not in itself constitute compensable damage.
A catalogue of individual factors determines claims under Art. 82 GDPR
The CJEU and the FCJ have held that an infringement alone does not justify compensation, analyd that the individual data subject’s specific circumstances bear on both the existence and the extent of damage (CJEU: C-300/21 – Österreichische Post; C-200/23 – Agentsia po vpisvaniyata; C-526/24 – Brillen Rottler; FCJ: VI ZR 10/24, VI ZR 396/24).
This applies equally to a loss of control over personal data: according to the CJEU, a loss of control is a potential cause of damage, not the damage itself. It may cause non-material damage only if the data subject demonstrates that he or she has actually suffered such damage (including negative consequences), however minimal (C-200/23 – Agentsia po vpisvaniyata, para. 156).
Building on this case law, the Berlin HRC identified a number of individual factors that might determine whether the prerequisites of a claim under Art. 82 GDPR and met and, if so, to what amount a data subject may actually recover non-material damages:
- Existence of a loss of control – as a possible cause of damage, not damage in itself under the CJEU’s jurisprudence – which may be excluded under a number of aspects, e.g. where the data subject freely and indiscriminately made his or her personal data public.
- Prior loss of control over the same data – also as a possible cause of damage, not damage in itself under the CJEU’s jurisprudence – which may preclude a claim under Art. 82 GDPR .
- Duration of the loss of control, which depends on the conduct of each data subject.
- Actual misuse of the data concerned.
- Sensitivity of the data concerned.
- Fear of the data subject, in particular whether the fear that the data subject’s personal data will be misused in the future owing to the existence of the GDPR infringement is well founded.
- Age and maturity of the data subject.
- Duration and frequency of use of a platform with regard to harm resulting from alleged influencing through advertising and content.
From these individual factors, the Berlin HRC drew the procedural consequence: what must be assessed individually cannot be decided collectively. It also rejected the claimant’s attempts to establish abstract damage standards, such as an ‘ordinary affected person’, ‘ordinary internet user’ or general rules of experience (Erfahrungssätze), since such abstract findings were neither possible nor compatible with German law and CJEU case law.
Takeaways and outlook for the FCJ hearing
- The 20th Senate of the Berlin HRC is not alone. In a redress action against a different social media platform concerning inter alia alleged GDPR infringements, another senate of the Berlin HRC has recently signalled similar doubts as to whether the claims are ‘essentially similar’ under the VDuG regime.
- A ruling with ripple effects. The FCJ’s decision is likely to shape comparable representative actions across Germany and give guidance on the similarity requirement for representative actions filed in Germany.
- The CJEU may have the final word. As a court of last instance, the FCJ may well be obliged to refer the question to the CJEU (Art. 267(3) TFEU). The hearing in February is therefore likely to be an important step, but (likely) not the last one.
- Exposure narrows, but does not disappear. The proceedings before the FCJ concern redress actions for damages only. Injunctive actions and individual mass claims remain available, even if the latter become harder to run at scale. Nor do they concern the German model declaratory action, which does not derive from the RAD.
