Find a lawyerOur capabilitiesYour career
Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

hamburger menu showcase image
  1. Our thinking
  2. Blogs
  3. Risk and Compliance
  4. Freshfields Annual Litigation Lecture 2026
7MIN

Freshfields Annual Litigation Lecture 2026

Oct 13 2026

At the Freshfields 2026 Annual Litigation Lecture, we were delighted to be joined by Mr Justice Butcher, former Financial List judge and now Lord Justice of Appeal, and Lord Justice Birss, President of the Business and Property Division and future Master of the Rolls. The lecture was chaired by Tom Clark, partner in Freshfields’ disputes practice. The lecture examined one of the most topical issues in the banking sector: the Quincecare duty post-Philipp v Barclays Bank UK Plc [2023] UKSC 25. It also looked at the Financial List in light of its recent ten-year anniversary. In the first part of this blog series, we take a look at the status of the Quincecare duty. In part two, we reflect on developments in the Financial List, past, present and future. 

The Quincecare duty 

The Supreme Court decision in Philipp clarified that the Quincecare cases were properly analysed through the lens of agency law (see our blog here). As a result, cases of authorised push payment (APP) fraud, where the customer gives the instructions but under false pretences, cannot form grounds for a claim. The claimant’s primary claim on the basis of the Quincecare duty was therefore summarily dismissed. This reflects that, in general, a bank can rely on the apparent authority of an authorised agent of the customer to give instructions on behalf of the principal. However, where a bank has reasonable grounds for believing that a payment instruction given by an agent is an attempt to defraud the customer, it will be ’on notice’ that the agent lacks authority. In such circumstances, the bank will be required to refrain from executing the instructions without first making further reasonable enquiries. Where the bank fails to do so, it will breach its duty of care to the customer.

Fraud by an agent 

The decision in Philipp did not directly address instances where the dishonest acts of an agent can be attributed to the customer, with the result that the customer cannot then claim that the bank acted in breach of its duty. Obiter, Lord Leggatt adopted the orthodox line as set out in Bowstead and Reynolds on Agency: an act of an agent within authority does not cease to bind the principal simply because the agent is dishonest. This is consistent with the Supreme Court decision in Singularis Holdings v Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Ltd [2019] UKSC 50, which found that a bank cannot argue that the actions of a rogue director who is the ‘dominant mind’ of the company can be attributed to the company. Otherwise, the director's fraud on the company would render the bank’s duty of care nugatory (Singularis at [34]–[35]). 

This issue was further considered in Arena Television Ltd (in liquidation) v Bank of Scotland Plc and Another [2025] EWHC 3036 (Comm). Arena’s liquidators claimed that the defendant banks processed payment instructions by the company’s dishonest directors without apparent authority in breach of the Quincecare duty. The defendant banks attempted to bypass Singularis by arguing that the fraud was engineered by the company against external lenders, rather than an internal fraud on the company’s own assets. It was argued that the company’s articles of association could be construed as permitting transactions that were dishonest to the benefit of the company, but not dishonest transactions to strip the company of assets (Arena at [24]). This has been coined as the defence of fraud by the company (Quincecare does not apply), as compared to fraud on the company (Quincecare may apply where the bank is on notice of the fraud). As a result, the defendant banks sought summary determination or strike out of the claims. The High Court decided that this and other related issues could not be determined summarily and leave to appeal was refused.

More recently, the Court of Appeal decision in Hamblin and Another v Moorwand Ltd and RND Global Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 942 (see further below) noted the Singularis line of authorities and concluded that the outcome of these decisions ‘has been the source of enduring controversy’ and such ‘issues, and no doubt others, will require full argument and careful consideration in a case in which they arise’ (Hamblin at [57] and [72]). The decisions suggest that establishing fraud by the company as a defence to a Quincecare claim is unlikely to be a matter that can be summarily determined. This reflects the established position that attribution is fact-sensitive and dependent on the purpose of the transfer (Hamblin at [71]–[72]). We may have some clarity on the issue if the Arena claim does reach trial, which is currently fixed for October 2028. 

Warranties to establish fraud by the company 

A further relevant factor in establishing fraud on the company, which was mentioned in Hamblin, is whether a bank may be able to rely on contractual warranties confirming the legitimacy of the company’s business. Foxton LJ indicated that such provisions could be relied on by the bank to claim breach of contract by way of a defence of circuity of action (Hamblin at [71]). Banks should therefore consider whether they need to update their terms and conditions, particularly for corporate accounts, to include warranties confirming the legitimacy of instructions by authorised agents. 

Further potential areas of liability

Beyond the classic case of Quincecare, that is an agent giving unauthorised instructions on behalf of a customer, there may be additional potential grounds for pursuing claims. These include:

  • Lack of capacity: A claim may arise where a bank has reasonable grounds to believe that the customer lacks the mental capacity to manage their account or financial affairs. This is a growing risk given uncertainty around the extent to which lack of capacity can give grounds to challenge subsequent payment instructions.
  • Retrieval duty: The Supreme Court in Philipp did not dismiss the claimants’ alternative claim based on a duty on the bank sending the funds to take steps to retrieve the assets once the fraud was identified. This aspect of the claim was therefore remitted back to the High Court. However, the case settled shortly thereafter. Since then, there has been limited judicial assessment of the scope of the duty on sending banks. Nonetheless, the judgments of Santander UK Plc v CCP Graduate School Ltd [2025] EWHC 667 (KB) and Larsson v Revolut Ltd [2024] EWHC 1287 (Ch) indicate that it is unlikely that a receiving bank will be subject to a retrieval duty.
  • Dishonest assistance: Banks may also face claims on the grounds of dishonest assistance in breach of trust. However, the threshold for these claims is generally high as can be seen in Singularis. In that case, the Quincecare claim was permitted but the parallel dishonest assistance claim was dismissed by the High Court and was not challenged as part of the subsequent appeals to the Supreme Court. 
  • Unjust enrichment: The issue of whether an unjust enrichment claim can arise in cases of APP fraud was briefly considered in Terna v Revolut [2024] EWHC 1419 (Comm). An attempt by the defendant to obtain reverse summary judgment or to dismiss the claim summarily was refused and the case has since settled. Whether such a claim is therefore arguable remains to be tested fully at trial. 
  • Extended Quincecare duty: Banks receiving fraudulently transferred funds into a company account may face claims from the customer of the bank sending the funds on the grounds of a constructive trust or a derivative claim on behalf of a company:
    • Beneficiaries of a constructive trust: In Hamblin v World First Limited and Moorwand NL Limited [2020] EWHC 2383 (Comm), the victims claimed that a company used as a vehicle for the fraud was a constructive trustee that held the fraudulently transferred funds on their behalf as beneficiaries. The defendants' application to strike out the claim failed, and the matter settled shortly after the interim judgment. 
    • Derivative claims: In a claim arising from the same underlying fraud, a County Court decision allowed a derivative claim by the claimant on behalf of another company used as the vehicle for the fraud. This aspect of the decision was not appealed as part of subsequent proceedings before the Court of Appeal (Hamblin and Another v Moorwand Ltd and RND Global Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 942); therefore, the issue was neither examined by the High Court nor subject to full appellate assessment.

Although these claims were not dismissed on summary assessment, they may face challenges at a full trial, particularly as the decisions contrast significantly with the Privy Council judgment in RBS International v JP SPC 4 [2022] UKPC 18. There, it was held that investors in a defrauded fund could not sue the bank directly in tort because the fund, which was the customer of the account, rather than the investor, was the bank’s customer, meaning there was insufficient proximity between the parties. If a duty arises based on a derivative claim, this circumvents the limitations on the Quincecare duty owed by the bank to its customers and to third parties in tort. 

Further analysis of these potential grounds for claims can be found in our article here. 

The road ahead

There is a lack of clarity on several aspects of the Quincecare duty and related grounds for claims following the Philipp decision. Many of the decisions assessing the grounds for claims are interim, and there is limited case law at the appellate level and/or following a full trial. The immediate focus will be on how the courts resolve the upcoming trial in Arena. The decision may help to resolve the long-standing debate surrounding the traditional Bowstead and Reynolds formulation on the authority of agents. 

Tags

disputesfinancial institutionslitigationfinancial servicesfinancial services litigationcommercial litigationfinancial disputesfinancial servicesunited kingdom

Authors

London

Tom Clark

Partner
London

Laura Feldman

Barrister
Latest Insights

Latest Insights

NAVIGATE TO
About usLocations and officesYour careerOur thinkingOur capabilitiesNews
CONNECT
Find a lawyerAlumniContact us
NEED HELP
Fraud and scamsComplaintsTerms and conditions
LEGAL
AccessibilityCookiesLegal noticesTransparency in supply chains statementResponsible procurementPrivacy

Select language:
Select language:
© 2026 Freshfields. Attorney Advertising: prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome