Carried Interest Not Subject to VAT: First Fiscal Court Ruling in Germany
Background
Same payment, different VAT treatment: To date, there is no consistent approach in Germany to the value-added tax (VAT) treatment of a fund initiator’s carried interest. Now, for the first time, a fiscal court has ruled on this issue – in favor of the taxpayer. The ruling is final.
Initiators of venture capital and private equity funds routinely receive performance-dependent payments in the form of increased (disproportionate) profit shares (so-called carried interest). The tax authorities of certain federal states take the view that carried interest qualifies as taxable compensation for services rendered by the fund initiator to the fund. Tax authorities of other federal states treat carried interest for VAT purposes as part of the profit allocation and classify carried interest payments as not taxable due to the absence of a service against compensation. In a ruling dated 7 May 2026 (case ref. 5 K 100/25), the Fiscal Court of Lower Saxony became the first fiscal court to address the VAT treatment of carried interest. The Fiscal Court held that the carried interest payments in the case at hand were not subject to VAT.
Decision of the Fiscal Court
The plaintiff, as the managing limited partner (geschäftsführende Kommanditistin) of a private equity fund organized as a German limited partnership (GmbH & Co. KG), received, upon the liquidation of the KG, an advance settlement payment equal to 20% of the increase in value of the partnership’s assets (liquidation carry), as well as a capital-proportionate share of the remaining liquidation proceeds.
The competent tax office treated both the liquidation carry and the plaintiff’s share of the remaining liquidation proceeds as taxable, assuming that both payments were compensation for "expertise services" provided by the plaintiff.
The plaintiff succeeded in getting the Fiscal Court to uphold its claim. The court argued that due to the absence of services rendered for compensation, neither the liquidation carry nor the plaintiff’s share of the remaining liquidation surplus is subject to VAT, i.e., there is no VAT on the carried interest. In the view of the court, regardless of whether and what specific, individualized services the plaintiff has provided to the fund, the liquidation carry agreed upon in the partnership agreement and the remaining share of the liquidation proceeds cannot be classified as special compensation (Sonderentgelt). The payments cannot qualify as special compensation because, on the one hand, there is no predetermined fixed amount. On the other hand, neither the liquidation carry nor the remaining liquidation proceeds compensate for a service provided by the plaintiff to the fund by reference to its scope or volume.
The court held that while the liquidation carry does structurally differ from the remaining share of the liquidation proceeds by virtue of its performance-dependent nature, neither exhibits the character of consideration for a service. The mere fact that the payment is linked to achieving a specific performance metric (hurdle rate) influenced by the plaintiff through its "activity" does not establish a direct link between the payment and services rendered by the plaintiff. On the contrary, both the liquidation carry and the remaining share of the fund’s liquidation proceeds are contingent on profits influenced by external circumstances and are thus dependent on chance. The amount of liquidation proceeds distributed to the limited partners, as well as the amount of the liquidation carry, varies – regardless of whether the plaintiff engages in more or fewer activities – with the liquidation surplus. The liquidation surplus depends on market conditions, timing, and external factors, rather than on the intensity of the plaintiff’s performance. Consequently, there is no taxable service against compensation.
Practical Consequences
Given the inconsistent VAT treatment of carried interest in venture capital and private equity fund structures by the German tax authorities, the ruling of the Fiscal Court of Lower Saxony represents an important and positive development and aligns with the Federal Fiscal Court’s (Bundesfinanzhof) classification of carried interest as a profit participation for income tax purposes. The tax office’s decision not to appeal on points of law (Revision) may indicate a shift in the tax authorities’ stance, particularly as the Federal Fiscal Court’s assessment of carried interest for income tax purposes was only recently adopted by the German tax authorities following the publication of the ruling dated 11 December 2018, VIII R 11/16, in the Federal Tax Gazette (BStBl.) II 2026, p. 611. Nevertheless, legal uncertainties remain as long as there is no decision by the Federal Fiscal Court recognized by the tax authorities or a uniform, binding guidance from the tax authorities regarding the VAT treatment of carried interest. The tax authorities are not bound by the ruling of the Fiscal Court of Lower Saxony beyond the specific case in question.
To avoid disputes with the tax authorities, partnership agreements should (continue to) strictly distinguish between (taxable) fixed, results-independent activity compensation of the fund initiator on the one hand, and the (non-taxable) carried interest of the fund initiator as a results-dependent component of profit distribution, on the other hand. Any descriptions of activities should, as far as possible, only be made in connection with the activity compensation, and the activity as a whole should be governed by a separate contract. Furthermore, it must be ensured that carried interest is measured solely by the achievement of a specific performance metric and not by the scope and volume of any specific activities. Moreover, carried interest should not be treated as an expense of the fund. For cases comparable to the adjudicated case that have already been challenged by the tax authorities, the ruling of the Fiscal Court of Lower Saxony provides a strong argument against a VAT liability for the carried interest.
Particular caution is required where carried interest is not granted to a partner/shareholder participating in the fund but is promised on a contractual basis to a non-participating management or advisory company. In the absence of partner/shareholder status, a service separable from the partnership/shareholder relationship may exist, the taxability of which is not excluded even in the case of performance-dependent compensation.
