Find a lawyerOur capabilitiesYour career
Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

hamburger menu showcase image
  1. Our thinking
  2. Blogs
  3. Transactions
  4. Navigating unbundling rules in energy and infrastructure M&A
5MIN

Navigating unbundling rules in energy and infrastructure M&A

Subscribe
Nov 16 2026

Unbundling rules in the EU may substantially shape an M&A deal in the energy sector, in particular for anyone considering stakes in a transmission system operator (TSO). This blog summarises the key rules and what they mean for financial investors.

At a glance: unbundling rules in the EU

In the electricity and gas sectors, five main activities are subject to different organisational rules and obligations: production, transmission, distribution, supply and storage. The operation of energy transmission and distribution systems is regulated, while energy generation, storage and supply take place in competitive markets. The core rules are set out by the Electricity Market Directive (Directive (EU) 2019/944) and the Directive on common rules for the internal markets for renewable gas, natural gas and hydrogen (Directive (EU) 2024/1788). Under these directives, the unbundling principle requires the separation of transmission activities from production and supply activities. Its aim is to prevent conflicts of interest, discriminatory practices and cross-subsidisation or distortion of competition between energy activities. 

In Germany, the gas transmission system is operated by 12 TSOs organised in the industry association FNB Gas, including Gasunie Deutschland and ONTRAS, while the electricity transmission network is operated by four TSOs: Amprion, TransnetBW, TenneT, and 50Hertz. 

Who may own and control a TSO? 

The unbundling rules also affect the governance of TSOs. The default model is Ownership Unbundling (OU). Under OU, the same person or persons (natural or legal), are not entitled to directly or indirectly exercise control over an undertaking performing production or supply, and at the same time, directly or indirectly exercise control or exercise any right over a TSO or a transmission system. The same applies in reverse, and the same person may not have board-level involvement in both. Electricity and gas are assessed together: control over gas production or supply is equally relevant for a stake in an electricity TSO, and vice versa. Where the transmission system belonged to a vertically integrated undertaking on 3 September 2009, EU Member States may allow alternative (and less restrictive) unbundling models: A TSO may also be certified as an Independent System Operator (ISO) or Independent Transmission Operator (ITO). An ISO is an entity that operates and controls a transmission system independently of its owners, with the network owner remaining obligated but losing operational control. With the ITO, the TSO remains affiliated with generation and supply but is required to operate independently under strict regulatory oversight and governance rules to prevent conflicts of interest. The unbundling rules must therefore be thoroughly assessed when a purchaser is considering the acquisition of shares in a TSO.

In Germany, these rules are implemented in the Energy Industry Act (Energiewirtschaftsgesetz – EnWG), which makes all three models available: OU (Section 8 EnWG), ISO (Section 9 EnWG) and ITO (Sections 10 to 10e EnWG). Germany uses more than one model in practice: 50Hertz and TenneT are ownership-unbundled, whereas Amprion and TransnetBW, as well as several gas TSOs, are certified as ITOs. Where a TSO is controlled by a person from a non-EU country, Section 4b EnWG additionally requires confirmation by the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy that the certification does not endanger the security of energy supply in Germany and the EU; the European Commission is consulted in this process.

Impact on the acquisition process and timetable

TSOs are subject to an approval and certification procedure by the regulatory authority, in Germany, the Federal Network Agency (BNetzA). They must notify the regulatory authority of any planned transaction that could lead to a reassessment of compliance with the unbundling rules. For example, in case of a change in the share capital of a TSO, a re-certification by the authority may become necessary. In such a case, the authority will verify that there is no conflict of interest, i.e. that no investor acquires control in the TSO which also has control over an undertaking that produces or supplies energy. The regulatory authorities will screen all participations from a financial investor to determine whether there is such a conflict of interest. As these procedures involve the European Commission and can take several months, they need to be built into the transaction timetable from the outset. 

For financial investors, unbundling is not a bar to investing in networks, but it needs to be addressed early in the structuring of a deal. Institutional investors already hold significant stakes in German TSOs, such as in the case of Amprion and TenneT. For a diversified investor that also holds generation or supply assets, the key question is whether those assets and the TSO stake are attributed to the same person. This requires a careful review of the fund and governance structure, including assets outside the EU. In its certification practice, the European Commission has accepted investor structures that rely, for example, on robust ring-fencing and governance safeguards ensuring that the investor acts as a passive financial investor in relation to the TSO. Ownership unbundling only becomes relevant where a TSO stake is combined with generation or supply interests; distribution system operators are subject to legal and functional, but not ownership, unbundling requirements.

Key regulatory developments on hydrogen

With the adoption of Directive (EU) 2024/1788, the EU has extended unbundling to the hydrogen sector. Since 5 August 2026, hydrogen transmission network operators (HTNOs) must be vertically unbundled. This means that the activities of operating a hydrogen network must be separated from hydrogen production and supply. To comply with this obligation, the models of unbundling already familiar from the electricity and gas sectors are available: ownership unbundling, in defined cases the designation of an integrated hydrogen transmission network operator and the model of the independent hydrogen transmission network operator.

With regard to horizontal unbundling, Directive (EU) 2024/1788 stipulates that a HTNO that is part of an undertaking active in the transmission or distribution of natural gas or electricity must at least be legally independent. This means that a TSO wishing to convert part of its infrastructure to hydrogen must do so through an independent legal entity, unless a derogation applies. Member States may grant such derogations on the basis of a public, positive cost-benefit analysis, provided that the regulatory authority assesses the impact of the derogation on transparency, cross-subsidisation, network tariffs and cross-border trade positively. This option was introduced in response to criticism which the legal unbundling obligation has received from the industry, as it discourages the conversion of gas pipelines into hydrogen pipelines.

Key takeaways for deals

For investors, the practical message is simple: unbundling should be considered at the very start of any transaction involving energy networks. Investors should map their existing generation, supply and network interests (including assets outside the EU) and, where necessary, design ring-fencing and governance arrangements. Certification and recertification procedures should be reflected in the deal timetable. Approached this way, unbundling becomes a well manageable part of what can be an attractive investment. 

To receive the latest insights on transactions and deal-making, subscribe to the Freshfields Transactions Blog.

Tags

globalantitrust and competitionenergy and real assetsenergy transitionglobal projectsmergers and acquisitionsprivate equitypublic m&aenergyindustrialsinfrastructureeuropegermany

Authors

Düsseldorf

Dominic Divivier

Partner
Berlin, Düsseldorf

Philipp Reinecke

Principal Associate
Düsseldorf

Julian Siegmund

Principal Associate
Latest Insights

Latest Insights

NAVIGATE TO
About usLocations and officesYour careerOur thinkingOur capabilitiesNews
CONNECT
Find a lawyerAlumniContact us
NEED HELP
Fraud and scamsComplaintsTerms and conditions
LEGAL
AccessibilityCookiesLegal noticesTransparency in supply chains statementResponsible procurementPrivacy

Select language:
Select language:
© 2026 Freshfields. Attorney Advertising: prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome