Find a lawyerOur capabilitiesYour careerSearch
Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

Locations
Our capabilities
News

Select language:

hamburger menu showcase image
  1. Our thinking
  2. International arbitration in 2025
  3. Human rights and social issues in investment treaty arbitration: a growing trend
Human rights and social issues in investment treaty arbitration: a growing trend
hero-image-0
In brief

Human rights and social issues are becoming more central to investment treaty arbitration. Natural resource, energy and infrastructure projects are often located in proximity to local and indigenous communities. As a result, the interaction between these projects and communities is increasingly at issue in investor-state disputes. At the same time, some newer generation treaties are seeking to expressly address these social and human rights issues. We expect to see this trend to continue.

By Caroline Richard, Carsten Wendler, Lluis Paradell, Vasuda Sinha, Carla Yoon and Domen Tursic

In detail

International treaties, such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the American Convention on Human Rights, the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, require states to protect human rights. Additionally, international business and human rights standards, such as the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights and the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises, call upon investors to respect human rights and to exercise due diligence to safeguard human rights. Against this backdrop, multinational corporations develop their own policy commitments, codes of conduct and sustainability policies reflecting these standards.

Alongside international requirements, there has been a proliferation of domestic regulation to protect human rights, including legislation relating to supply chains as well as the protection of indigenous rights. Such developments can arise from new legislation, as seen in Canada, but often stem from court rulings, as in South Africa and Ecuador.

Financial institutions, including the International Finance Corporation, may also condition the provision of project finance on compliance with human rights-related requirements.

This growing mix of hard- and soft-law requirements are a key consideration when developing projects. Mining companies, for example, rank community impact and indigenous trust among their top five considerations and risk factors in 2025. States have invoked community consultation requirements to annul or terminate concessions and land titles. For instance, citing non-compliance with consultation requirements, Mexico terminated a contract for a major wind farm and revoked gold and silver mining concessions. Similarly, in Kenya, courts invalidated land titles for wind farm projects.

Investors and states must navigate these international and domestic frameworks in the context of operating and overseeing major projects. Increasingly, human rights and social issues are being raised in the context of investment disputes.

Looking ahead

Social and human rights issues are increasingly at issue in investment treaty disputes. Social issues are often the catalyst for state measures leading to investment treaty claims. They are also increasingly being raised by states both as a shield and a sword in investment treaty arbitration, i.e. as defences to investment claims or even as a basis for counterclaims. Separately, newer treaties are expressly referring to human rights norms. We expect this area to continue to develop over the coming years, as more tribunals are faced with such issues and interpret new treaties. Our team has vast experience in successfully navigating these new challenges.

International arbitration in 2025

International arbitration in 2025

Jan 28 2025
AI in international arbitration: a fast-evolving landscape

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing industries worldwide. International arbitration is no exception. 

Jan 28 2025
Geopolitical shifts: new political agendas driving investment treaty claims

In 2025, investment claims are likely to be shaped by major geopolitical shifts that have developed in recent years.

Jan 28 2025
Russian disputes and anti-suit injunctions: arbitration and state courts - allies, adversaries, or both?

In 2024, national court intervention in arbitration continued to intensify, particularly in relation to disputes with sanctioned Russian companies.

Jan 28 2025
Investor-state mediation: a bridge over troubled waters?

Mediation, as a third-party facilitated negotiation controlled by the parties, has the potential to reinvigorate investor-state dispute resolution in the years ahead. 

Jan 28 2025
Human rights and social issues in investment treaty arbitration: a growing trend

Human rights and social issues are becoming more central to investment treaty arbitration. 

Jan 28 2025
Arbitration as a tool for private capital disputes

We anticipate an increase in disputes arising from deals in the private capital space.

Jan 28 2025
Arbitration of space disputes: time for take-off

The space industry is set to accelerate in 2025, with a surge in satellite launches and the roll-out of cutting-edge satellite-based services.

Jan 28 2025
Game-changing sports disputes: a new normal

The sports industry is undergoing rapid transformation, with tech companies competing with legacy broadcasters for lucrative media rights, while institutional investors are acquiring stakes in leagues and teams.

Jan 28 2025
Privilege in arbitration – should one set of rules apply?

International arbitration offers a neutral forum for resolving disputes between parties from different jurisdictions.

Jan 28 2025
The shift from EPC to EPCM: a recipe for more complex arbitrations?

As EPCM contract structures gain popularity in global projects, related disputes will become increasingly complex.

Jan 28 2025
The internationalization of arbitration in Brazil: a rising trend

This trend has multiple implications, with the most notable being the increasing internationalization of arbitrations seated in Brazil.

Jan 28 2025
Shifting sands: the Middle East’s evolution into an arbitration hub

Arbitration has a complicated legacy in the Middle East. Investors have historically been suspicious of arbitration in the region due to perceived judicial hostility to alternative dispute resolution, especially when a state-owned entity is involved.

Contacts

Contacts

View more
Washington, DC
Caroline RichardPartner
Frankfurt am Main
Carsten WendlerPartner
Rome, Madrid
Lluís Paradell TriusCounsel
Washington, DC
Carla Sung Ah YoonAssociate
Frankfurt am Main
Domen TursicAssociate
View more
FIND US IN
All locations
NAVIGATE TO
About usYour careerOur thinkingOur capabilitiesNews
CONNECT
Find a lawyerAlumniContact us
NEED HELP
Fraud and scamsComplaintsTerms and conditions
LEGAL
AccessibilityCookiesLegal noticesTransparency in supply chains statementResponsible procurementPrivacy

© 2025 Freshfields. Attorney Advertising: prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome

Select language: